Skip to content Skip to navigation

Lesbian Historic Motif Podcast Episode 357 – Our F/Favorite Tropes Part 20: Carnival and Masquerades

Saturday, November 21, 2026 - 07:00

Lesbian Historic Motif Podcast - Episode 357 – Our F/Favorite Tropes Part 20: Carnival and Masquerades - transcript

(Originally aired 2026/11/21)

In this series of shows about tropes and character types, I’m examining popular historic romance tropes and how they work differently for female couples as opposed to mixed-gender couples, and in some cases in contrast with male couples. As used for romance novels, tropes are a motif, a character type, or a type of relationship that repeats across multiple books and which creates certain types of reader expectations and experiences. In general I’m focusing on tropes that do have a gendered element to them, either in terms of the types of activities engaged in by women versus men, or where the social dynamics of a situation rely on assumptions about gendered interactions and their implications.

Today’s episode expands on a topic covered previously: the potential for disguise and masquerade to inspire or enable romance. I’ve covered aspects of this trope previously in an episode about gender disguise and a pair of episodes about actresses and the stage. So today I won’t be focusing much on cross-gender masquerades and will discuss professional theater only as part of the background for carnival and masquerade events.

In historic romance novels, masquerades and carnivals offer the opportunity for your characters to meet anonymously. Whether a mask conceals the specific identity of an individual, or a costume presents a different occupation or station in life, or even disguises the gender of the person, there is broad scope for people to meet who would not ordinarily interact, and for sparks to fly between people who might otherwise instantly rule out a romance.

Western culture has embraced a variety of formalized contexts for pretending to be someone you’re not. The most obvious—and most obviously fictional—is the theatrical stage. This can encompass commercial theater, private amateur theatricals, and formal court masques. The romantic possibilities in a theater environment often involve tempting the viewer (or performer) to imagine themself in a different role, and thus to open the mind and heart to other possibilities. Women participated in private theatricals from the medieval era onward, even in cultures where they were not allowed on the public professional stage. Masques were often a hybrid type of entertainment, with costumed courtiers of both sexes performing the physical roles while professional musicians and singers provided the songs and speeches. Masques were particularly popular in the 16th and 17th centuries across most of western Europe. The participation of women on the professional stage was discussed in the earlier episode.

In a theatrical setting, everyone understands that the actor is not the role they are portraying, although there may be symbolic correspondences between people and their roles in court masques. Generally the participants and audience are aware of the true identity of the performers on stage. The setting can provide license to display charms or invite attentions in a way that would not be acceptable in everyday life, but unless the circumstances are exceptional, true identities are known.

The less formal setting of Carnival allowed for more daring and transgressive masquerades and for a much greater concealment of identity. Carnival originated in the pre-Lenten “farewell to meat” (carne vale) that preceded fasting in the lead-up to Easter. Carnival offered a general sense of indulgence and freedom from ordinary rules and conventions that included costumes and disguises. This license could vary in different locations. In the 18th century, the German writer Goethe criticized the mixing of social classes during Italian carnival celebrations, as he was more familiar with German restrictions on participation in masquerade balls by the servants and lower classes. So the specific opportunities that carnival might offer can depend on setting.

Carnival role-playing contributed to other theatrical traditions, such as Italian commedia but also to public masquerades balls that were only loosely associated with the Catholic church calendar. In a variety of forms, these masquerade balls were popular throughout Europe, but I’m going to focus specifically on England.

English society of the 18th century had a strong preoccupation with masquerades and disguises, supporting the rise of public masquerade balls. These events were popular among both the upper and lower classes and social mixing was part of the attraction. Although this masquing may have had its origins in the more limited escapades of carnival, it became far more pervasive in 18th century practice and continued to some extent into the 19th century.

Public masquerades in England were open to anyone who paid the entrance fee and thus were attended by people of a wide variety of social classes. This, combined with the effects of costume and masks to conceal the identity (including the gender) of the attendees made them an ideal setting for assignations, casual hook-ups, and comedies of errors. Public masquerades played with all manner of false identities: gender, class, occupation, and ethnicity. Popular costumes included historic dress, “exotic” foreign costume, especially Turkish outfits, religious costumes, outfits depicting various working-class occupations, and theatrical characters such as Harlequin. In addition to dancing, gaming, and social mingling, masquerade events offered food and drink. They were typically held at night, in an elaborately decorated space, and lasted until morning. In addition to the regular ticketed masquerades, even larger outdoor events were sometimes held for special occasions.

Masquerades were the targets of moralistic pamphlets, as well as the cautionary writings of advice manuals and popular fiction. Like many “vices” they were attacked as being a foreign import, echoing the famous carnivals of Mediterranean regions. Both their threat and their appeal derived from a sort of “institutionalized disorder” in which social norms and barriers were cast aside and social hierarchies of class and gender could be inverted.

Within the sexual realm, masquerades offered the opportunity not only for cross-dressing, but for engaging in other superficially transgressive liaisons under the fiction invoked by the costumes. At the same time, the theatrical and performative nature of the events provided cover and excuse for sexual liberties. One could always claim to be role-playing.

For women, the masquerade offered both opportunity and danger. Anonymity and the conventions of the event gave women the freedom to mingle and to initiate interactions with strangers. This freedom was also available regardless of rank, and anti-masquerade literature railed against the social leveling as well as the licentiousness. The crowds could also include thieves, card sharps, highwaymen, and sex workers, all taking advantage of both the anonymity and of distracted targets.

But in particular, women had a freedom unavailable in their ordinary lives to attend as free agents, without chaperones or concern for their reputations as long as they remained masked. (Though conversely, a woman known to attend masquerades was assumed to have damaged her reputation, regardless of her actual actions.) This was a key factor in criticism of masquerades. In an era when “good” women were expected not to make a spectacle of themselves, masquerades were all about becoming part of the spectacle.

The English public masquerade tradition faded away by the end of the 18th century, though more private and exclusive costumed balls continued to be held, without the same opportunities and hazards of the previous version.

Once we’ve set aside the gender-disguise possibilities of a masquerade, and acknowledged the unusual freedom for women of all classes to participate, the romantic possibilities for female couples are not that different from those for heterosexual couples. Anonymity offers the opportunity to make romantic overtures that would ordinarily be taboo. Most obviously, this includes same-sex overtures. Imagine your heroine costuming herself as Sappho in Greek draperies and reciting love poetry (in character) to fair damsels. Or wearing a Turkish outfit and playing to the rumors of what goes on within the seraglio. Or she might take on the role of a courtesan, or for that matter, of an actress—professions with a reputation for sapphic excursions. Regardless of the part being played, the masquerade offers a chance to interact as an equal with someone of a wildly different class or background. For that matter, your heroine might encounter someone she believes to be of a different class or background, only to find later that they have much in common.

In every case, there is the potential for a Cinderella scenario where your heroine must desperately try to find her true love afterward, while having no idea who she really is. There can be misdirection, misunderstanding, acting at cross-purposes, or fear of being unmasked and revealed. Plenty of romantic conflict to play with! All you need to do is plan how they’ll work it out in the end.

Show Notes

In this episode we talk about:

  • Romance tropes involving carnival or masquerade disguises and anonymity
  • Selected References
    • Castle, T. 1983-4. “Eros and Liberty at the English Masquerade, 1710-90” in Eighteenth-Century Studies, XVII, 2: 156-76.
    • Dugaw, Dianne. 1989. Warrior Women and Popular Balladry 1650-1850. The University of Chicago Press, Chicago. ISBN 0-226-16916-2
    • Frangos, Jennifer. 2009 “The Woman in Man’s Clothes and the Pleasures of Delarivier Manley’s ‘New Cabal’” in Sexual Perversions, 1670–1890, ed. by Julie Peakman. Palgrave Macmillan, London. ISBN 978-1-349-36397-1 pp.95-116
    • Katritzky, M.A. 2005. “Reading the Actress in Commedia Imagery” in Women Players in England, 1500-1660: Beyond the All-Male Stage, edited by Pamela Allen Brown & Peter Parolin. Ashgate, Burlington. ISBN 978-0-7546-0953-7
    • Krimmer, Elisabeth. 2004. In the Company of Men: Cross-Dressed Women Around 1800. Wayne State University Press, Detroit. ISBN 0-8143-3145-9

Links to the Lesbian Historic Motif Project Online

Links to Heather Online

Major category: 
historical